Giovanni van Bronckhorst has had a successful tenure with Feyenoord, but Ally McCoist is uncertain about whether he can immediately lead Liverpool to success. McCoist is wary of the potential departure of key players from Liverpool, which he believes could disrupt van Bronckhorst’s plans. He also expressed concern about Liverpool’s recent form, with only one win in their last five games. McCoist stated on talkSPORT that he doubts van Bronckhorst’s ability to win the title in his first season with Liverpool, given the uncertainty surrounding the team, potential player exodus, and recent events such as the incident involving Klopp and Salah.

He emphasized the challenges that van Bronckhorst may face in his debut season at the club. McCoist’s skepticism is echoed by other pundits, one of whom compared van Bronckhorst’s arrival to the previous appointments of Rafa Benitez and Jurgen Klopp. They highlighted the heightened expectations and competitive aspirations of the current Liverpool team, emphasizing the significant leap that van Bronckhorst would have to make in order to achieve success. They acknowledged van Bronckhorst’s coaching credentials and track record but expressed a cautious approach to his prospects at Liverpool, noting the demanding nature of the club’s ambitions.